GARTH BROOKS – YANKEE STADIUM, NYC (July 9, 2016)
After years and years of hearing about how amazing Garth Brooks was as a live performer, I made my way into the Bronx on Saturday afternoon bracing myself for a once in a lifetime experience. When all was said and done at 2 a.m., my feelings were certainly mixed, mostly due to the unfortunate and confusing three plus hour rain delay. However, there is simply no way I could overlook the performance and spectacle that Garth put forth late into the night.
I got to my seat at approximately 8:15, just fifteen minutes before he was supposed to get on stage. I had just had an amazing dinner at NYY Steak and was feeling like the evening was set up perfectly to be a memorable experience. With a light drizzle in the air, the last thing I was thinking about was a delay. Even at 9:15, more than forty five minutes after the start time, with the entire Stadium seating filled to capacity, we all thought it was just a matter of time. But, then, the stage crew began to come out with tarps and plastic to fill the giant sized circle stage extension and we all began to fear there was a delay, despite there being no announcement. Finally, after 10 pm, more than one hour and a half from the start time, with still just a drizzle (if that) in the air, the Stadium announced we were in a rain delay. Most were furious, including me, that it took this long to make the announcement, but more so that they could have gotten most of the show in already. What was worse, was they cleared the pit and floor area, and alcohol sales ended. The scene within the Stadium was angry, tired, and anxious.
Finally at about 11 pm, we were allowed back to our seats. It had rained extremely hard during the 10 to 11 pm hour, but that did not make anyone feel better about the situation. At midnight (yes, freaking midnight), Garth finally took to the stage. There was simply no energy from the crowd at that point as people half heartedly clapped when he came out. I was expecting some dramatic entrance, but instead Garth just walked out and apologized for the wait. But then something unexpected happened, song by song he won back the crowd and energized the iconic Stadium deep into the night air.
From Rodeo to Two Pina Coladas to That Summer, it was clear Garth was going to do everything he could to salvage the night. He moved from side to side of the huge stage and even used the slick circle extension a few times. He told the crowd he was not going to be able to do some of the performance runs like he usually did (another bummer due to the rain), but all in all it was clear he was born to perform. And the crowd was in the palm of his energetic hands by the eighth song of the night as the huge screens flashed lighting and rumbled thunder as he put forth an amazing rendition of the epic Thunder Rolls, with the hidden verse included (to the crowd’s delight). From there on, the crowd was up and standing, singing, and dancing in unison.
He claimed that they were “making up the setlist as they went along”, but that was hardly true as it very much mirrored the night before, despite some changes and crowd requests. One such change from the previous night was my favorite Garth song of all time, “Much Too Young (Too Feel This Damn Old)”. The twang of his voice echoed in the Stadium and truly made me appreciate not only the mastery of his performance style, but the perfection of his voice in a Stadium, at that. Halfway through the show, his wife Trisha Yearwood came out to perform a five song set. The crowd went crazy when they shared an embrace at the end of In Another’s Eyes, but her solo performances of How Do I Live and She’s In Love With the Boy got two of the biggest responses from the fans all night. Her mid show set was a great change of pace and I got a new found respect for Trisha as a performer as well.
The true climax of the show occurred with the three songs before the rather forgettable encore, consisting of a bombastic Callin’ Baton Rouge, followed an epic sing-a-long Friends In Low Places and concluding with the heartfelt The Dance. No three songs may say more about Garth Brooks’ career in terms of the depth, reach, diversity, and passion he has for his music. After those three songs it really sunk in to me that I was seeing one of the best performers I’ve ever seen in the 500 or so concerts I have seen.
The encore was a mixed bag for me as I felt his best songs were already performed and it was so late (1:45 in the AM) I was beginning to expire. He ended the night with a Billy Joel cover of Piano Man followed by Standing Outside the Fire which included five minutes worth of fireworks, which seemed unnecessary due to it being 2 am. However, all in all, I am glad I waited out the annoying rain delay because the show itself was indeed a spectacle and Garth is a world class performer. But, I can’t help but feel like I was cheated out of the full Garth Brooks experience, but I guess that just means I will have to see him again in the future.
- 2 Pina Coladas
- That Summer
- You Move Me
- The River
- We Shall Be Free
- Night Moves
- The Thunder Rolls
- Papa Loved Mama
- Unanswered Prayers
- Much Too Young (To Feel This Damn Old)
- In Another’s Eyes (with Trish Yearwood)
- When Will I Be Loved (by Trish Yearwood)
- How I Live (by Trish Yearwood)
- Georgia Rain (by Trish Yearwood)
- She’s In Love With the Boy (by Trish Yearwood)
- Callin’ Baton Rouge
- Friends In Low Places
- The Dance
- She’s Every Woman (Encore)
- It’s Your Song (Encore)
- If Tomorrow Never Comes (Encore)
- Wrapped Up In You (Encore)
- Piano Man (Encore)
- Standing Outside the Fire (Encore)